Social Readjustment Rating Scale - Holmes and Rahe (1967)
Aim: To construct an instrument for measuring stress.
Method:
- Examined medical records of 5000 patients.
- Compiled a list of 43 life events.
- Told 100 people that marriage had the arbitrary value of 500 and they had to assign a number to the other life events.
- Death of a spouse was judged to require twice as much readjustment as marriage.
- The amount of stress a person has experienced in a given period is measured by the total amount of life change units.
Findings:
- Most life events were less stressful than marriage, but six (death of spouse, divorce, personal injury, illness) were rated more stressful.
- People with a high LCU score were more likely to experience physical illness the following year.
- Someone scoring over 300 LCU had an 80% chance of becoming ill.
Conclusions:
- Stress could be measured objectively as an LCU score.
Evaluation:
- Life changes have a largely negative feel about them so the SRRS may be confusing 'change' with 'negativity'.
- Some life events are ambiguous.
- It may not be change that's stressful, but the unexpected change.
- Gender bias
- Vague - measurement is not valid.
- Ignores individual differences.
- Not applicable to all population.
- Not relevant to modern day.
- Ethical issues.
--------------------------------
Rahe, Mahan and Arthur (1970)
Procedure:
- Crew of three naval ships - 2684 men - assessed for LCU in preceding two years .
- Spent 6-8 months onboard ship and naval medicine staff kept record of their illnesses.
Findings:
- Positive correlation found between life events in 6 months prior to departure and subsequent illness.
- Few pre-departure life events = onboard illness low.
- Results plotted against illness score.
- Various factors affected pattern, such as the overall stress level of the crew and their age and marital status.
Evaluation:
+ Natural experiment - reflects natural behaviour.
+ Longitudinal - over a long period of time.
- Androcentric.
- Longitudinal - attrition.
- Self-reprot technique - social desirability bias.
- Investigator bias - Rahe doing experiment - validity reduced.
- Can't be replicated - low reliability.
- Individual differences.
- Doesn't prove cause and effect.
No comments:
Post a Comment